Exploring the Acceptability of Virtual Reality Nature Environments for People with Memory Loss

Tagged:

The purpose of this study was to report on the acceptability of virtual reality (VR) nature environments for people with memory loss at memory cafes, and explore the experiences and perceptions of carers and staff.

A qualitative study was conducted between January and March 2019. Ten adults with memory loss, eight carers and six volunteer staff were recruited from two memory cafes, located in Cornwall, UK. There were 19 VR sessions which were audio recorded and all participants were interviewed at the end of the sessions. Framework analysis was used to identify patterns and themes in the data.

During the VR experience, participants were engaged to varying degrees, with engagement facilitated by the researcher, and in some cases, with the help of a carer. Participants responded positively to the nature scenes, finding them soothing and evoking memories. The VR experience was positive; many felt immersed in nature and saw it as an opportunity to ‘go somewhere’. However, it was not always positive and for a few, it could be ‘strange’. Participants reflected on their experience of the VR equipment, and volunteer staff and carers also shared their perceptions of VR for people with dementia in long-term care settings.

The VR nature experience was an opportunity for people with memory loss to be immersed in nature and offered the potential to enhance their quality of life. Future work should build on lessons learned and continue to work with people with dementia in developing and implementing VR technology in long-term care settings.

Geriatrics 06 00027 g001a 550Geriatrics 06 00027 g001b 550

 

The participants engaged with the VR nature environments to varying degrees, with many responding with quite detailed descriptions and commentaries on what they were seeing, and others commenting less and attempting to remove the headset before the end of the session. For example, one man with memory loss was animated throughout the experience:
I’m on the beach. Haven’t been on the beach in ages! Ooh, it’s lovely. Which beach is it, maid*?…Oh now I’m under the sea! Look at all these fishes. It’s good innit? Wow!…and now there’s someone comin’ in on a boat. Hello! Ahhh. The waves are lovely (10-ML) [*a Cornish dialect word for girl].
Another participant was similarly engaged and then after one and a half minutes stated that she had had enough:
It’s sort of a forest thing, and it’s got a path…like mountains an’ that as well. It’s very nice…Oh wow I can see a beach now. Oh yeah, it’s a bit like Polzeath it is, with people on it. Oh yeah, people playing games an’ that on the beach. It’s hot ‘cause they got their shorts and t-shirts on. It’s very nice. Oh I can see a pink bucket as well. A…a very busy beach…very busy…oh yeah, very nice. [inaudible] they’re going out in the boat now. Oh yeah, there’s a chap going out on the beach—on the boat now. Ooh, very nice. I’ve had enough now (05-ML).

 “It Makes You Feel That You Are There”

The VR experience often centred around immersion (and presence), and the opportunity to interact with others in a virtual world.
Participants reported that they felt immersed in nature: ‘at the sea’, ‘on the sand’ and ‘feeling the sand’ (“…It looks real, and you feel part of it” [06-V], “…with that, virtually, you’re in it, aren’t you? It’s fantastic” [11-V]):
Oh, now I’m in the sea with the fish!…Back on the beach. Who’s that over there? (13-ML)
It makes you feel as if you’re at the sea, right at the sea, doesn’t it?…it makes you feel that you are there [emphasis] on the sand, with the sea rolling in (15-V).
Another volunteer participant reflected on how the VR experience meant ‘you were there, in nature’
There were some negative responses to the VR nature experience, finding them potentially confusing or strange, such as this carer:
Well from what I saw of the little bits, when she [her Mother] was at the beach, she obviously quite liked that. I think under the water was a bit confusing for her.” (07-C)
One participant said “Yeah, it’s quite strange actually, ‘cause it’s not quite real. It’s got a strange light to it. Sort of, edges on the figures and things” 12-ML), and at one point found it frightening:
This study shows that people living with mild to moderate cognitive impairment who participated in a VR nature intervention had a sense of presence in the nature environments. Despite the importance of presence in VR being recognised, few studies on immersive VR in dementia have attempted to establish participant presence [9]. Given that presence is a subjective experience, the qualitative approach used in this study contributes to a developing field of research where evidence is still limited. It also enhances our understanding of the wellbeing benefits that people with mild to moderate memory loss can derive from a VR nature intervention, and shows promise for those living in long-term care. Since people with advanced dementia in residential care are less involved in activities, the VR nature intervention could be a way of engaging them in meaningful activity—with support from carers. Future work should build on lessons learned from this study and continue to work with people with dementia in developing and implementing VR technology in long-term care settings.

Related content

Research project

Interviews with participants: Green Social Prescribing Test and Learn Pilots extension project

'Green social prescribing’ (GSP) describes activities prescribed to people (e.g. by their doctor or a link worker) that take place in the outdoors, typically with other people, delivered by a specific organisation.
Research project

Feasibility study: Green Social Prescribing Test and Learn Pilots extension project

As part of the larger Green Social Prescribing (GSP) Test and Learn Pilots extension project, we are carrying out a feasibility study to understand and characterise the best experimental or quasi-experimental study design.
Research project

Green Social Prescribing Test and Learn Pilots extension project  

A consortium of researchers from The Universities of Sheffield, Plymouth, Exeter and Sheffield Hallam have been funded to evaluate a one year extension to the Government’s flagship Green Social Prescribing test and learn pilots programme.